{"id":"1582","title":"Epic and Google’s 2025 Settlement Proposal Faces Scrutiny","source_title":"When Rivals Suddenly Become Best Friends","url":"https://reinouttebrake.com/stories/when-rivals-suddenly-become-best-friends","published":"2025-11-12T20:49:57+01:00","modified":"2026-10-17T17:04:06.350Z","source_modified":"2025-11-12T20:49:57+01:00","author":{"name":"Reinout te Brake","url":"https://reinouttebrake.com/about","description":"Reinout te Brake is an entrepreneur, consultant, investor and board member with 20+ years in tech and gaming, advising CEOs, management teams and investors.","profiles":[{"name":"LinkedIn","url":"https://www.linkedin.com/in/reinouttebrake/"},{"name":"Facebook","url":"https://www.facebook.com/Reinoutttebrake"},{"name":"Instagram","url":"https://www.instagram.com/reinouttebrake/"},{"name":"X","url":"https://x.com/reinouttebrake"},{"name":"TikTok","url":"https://www.tiktok.com/@reinoutttebrake"},{"name":"Medium","url":"https://medium.com/@reinouttebrake"}]},"summary":"A November 2025 look at the proposed Epic–Google settlement, app-store fees and Judge James Donato’s questions about competition and transparency.","categories":[{"name":"Antitrust","slug":"antitrust"}],"tags":[{"name":"Antitrust","slug":"antitrust"},{"name":"Epic Games","slug":"epic-games"},{"name":"Google","slug":"google"}],"source_url":"https://reinouttebrakecom.wordpress.com/2025/11/12/when-rivals-suddenly-become-best-friends/","data_url":"https://reinouttebrake.com/data/articles/when-rivals-suddenly-become-best-friends.json","text_url":"https://reinouttebrake.com/stories/when-rivals-suddenly-become-best-friends.txt","markdown_url":"https://reinouttebrake.com/stories/when-rivals-suddenly-become-best-friends.md","reader_question":"Why did the judge question Epic and Google’s proposed settlement?","topic_guide":"https://reinouttebrake.com/topic/tech","content_html":"\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Two rivals who fought for years are suddenly best friends. Sounds fishy, right?</p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">A U.S. judge thinks so too.<br>Epic and Google showed up with a shiny plan to end their long courtroom battle and call it peace. The deal? Google would lower its <a href=\"/stories/the-battle-for-the-open-app-store-why-googles-appeal-matters\">app store</a> fees, nine or twenty percent, depending on how and when you install an app. Developers could set their own prices, use <a href=\"/stories/gamings-great-power-shift-how-developers-are-taking-back-control-in-2025\">other payment systems</a>, even run their own app stores. Sounds great on paper.</p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">But Judge James Donato, who’s been watching this circus since 2020, didn’t buy it.<br>“The only thing that’s changed,” he said, “is that Epic and Google, two mortal enemies who beat each other up for years in this courtroom, are suddenly BFFs.”</p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">He’s not convinced the market or Google’s behavior has actually changed. And he’s definitely not signing off on a deal done “in the dark.” Both companies wanted to keep the full details secret. Donato refused.</p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">There’ll be another hearing in December or January. Until then, we’ll see if this is a real turning point or just two giants cutting a convenient truce.</p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Meanwhile, Google can’t force U.S. developers to use its billing system anymore. And Epic’s Tim Sweeney? He called the deal “awesome.” Of course he did.<br>Because nothing says “open and fair competition” like making peace with the monopoly you once swore to destroy.</p>\n","content_text":"Two rivals who fought for years are suddenly best friends. Sounds fishy, right?\n\nA U.S. judge thinks so too.\nEpic and Google showed up with a shiny plan to end their long courtroom battle and call it peace. The deal? Google would lower its app store (https://reinouttebrake.com/stories/the-battle-for-the-open-app-store-why-googles-appeal-matters) fees, nine or twenty percent, depending on how and when you install an app. Developers could set their own prices, use other payment systems (https://reinouttebrake.com/stories/gamings-great-power-shift-how-developers-are-taking-back-control-in-2025), even run their own app stores. Sounds great on paper.\n\nBut Judge James Donato, who’s been watching this circus since 2020, didn’t buy it.\n“The only thing that’s changed,” he said, “is that Epic and Google, two mortal enemies who beat each other up for years in this courtroom, are suddenly BFFs.”\n\nHe’s not convinced the market or Google’s behavior has actually changed. And he’s definitely not signing off on a deal done “in the dark.” Both companies wanted to keep the full details secret. Donato refused.\n\nThere’ll be another hearing in December or January. Until then, we’ll see if this is a real turning point or just two giants cutting a convenient truce.\n\nMeanwhile, Google can’t force U.S. developers to use its billing system anymore. And Epic’s Tim Sweeney? He called the deal “awesome.” Of course he did.\nBecause nothing says “open and fair competition” like making peace with the monopoly you once swore to destroy.","referenced_links":[{"url":"https://reinouttebrake.com/stories/the-battle-for-the-open-app-store-why-googles-appeal-matters","label":"app store"},{"url":"https://reinouttebrake.com/stories/gamings-great-power-shift-how-developers-are-taking-back-control-in-2025","label":"other payment systems"}],"social_image":"https://reinouttebrake.com/assets/editorial/archive-photo-9072242-1280.webp","citation":"Reinout te Brake. Epic and Google’s 2025 Settlement Proposal Faces Scrutiny. 2025-11-12. https://reinouttebrake.com/stories/when-rivals-suddenly-become-best-friends"}