Epic v Google: A 2025 Look at the Play Store Appeal Author: Reinout te Brake Published: 2025-03-07T14:21:08+01:00 Updated: 2026-10-17T23:50:00+02:00 Canonical: https://reinouttebrake.com/stories/the-battle-for-the-open-app-store-why-googles-appeal-matters Source: https://reinouttebrake.com/stories/the-battle-for-the-open-app-store-why-googles-appeal-matters Editorial update — 17 October 2026. This article describes the appeal before a decision. On 31 July 2025, the Ninth Circuit affirmed the jury verdict and permanent injunction against Google. The comparison with Apple also needs care: the Apple litigation rejected Epic’s federal antitrust claims but upheld relief against anti-steering under California law; it was not an unconditional victory for Apple. These decisions provide later context for the earlier commentary. Ninth Circuit’s 31 July 2025 decision in Epic v Google (https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2025/07/31/24-6256.pdf) · Ninth Circuit’s 2023 decision in Epic v Apple (https://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2023/04/24/21-16506.pdf) The fight between Google and Epic Games isn’t just about Fortnite—it’s about who controls the future of mobile gaming (https://reinouttebrake.com/stories/150-billion-reasons-why-mobile-is-still-the-king) and app stores . As a gaming and tech entrepreneur , I see this as a crucial moment for developers, startups, and the entire industry . If you care about innovation , fair competition, and having real choices , you need to pay attention to this case. What’s Happening? Epic Games and Google are still fighting. Yes, there are! This time, it’s at the U.S. Court of Appeals , where Google is trying to overturn a major antitrust loss from last year. If you’re wondering, “Why should I care?” , here’s the deal: this case isn’t just about Epic Games and Fortnite. It’s about who controls mobile gaming (https://reinouttebrake.com/stories/supercells-biggest-lesson-why-brawl-stars-won-big-and-squad-busters-didnt), how developers can reach players, and whether you actually have a choice when it comes to app stores . Let’s break it down. Google vs. Epic: The Core of the Fight This all started in 2020 , when Epic Games tried to let Fortnite players buy in-game items directly from Epic , bypassing the Google Play Store and its 30% cut on transactions. Google (and Apple) weren’t happy. Both removed Fortnite from their app stores. Epic fired back with lawsuits, claiming this was anti-competitive behavior—a way for these tech giants to control the entire ecosystem and block alternatives. - Epic sued both Apple and Google. - Apple won in court, but Google lost in 2023. - Now, Google is appealing to get that ruling overturned. Why Google Lost, but Apple Won The reason Google lost while Apple won comes down to control . Apple owns the entire iPhone experience — hardware, iOS, and the App Store . That means they get to make the rules. Courts saw Apple as a closed ecosystem, not a monopoly. Google, on the other hand, doesn’t make most of the phones that run Android . It licenses Android to companies like Samsung and then pays them to keep competitors (like the Epic Games Store) off their devices. That’s where they got in trouble. Read also: The Future of Game Subscriptions — Why Engagement, Not Just Access, Will Define Success What’s at Stake? If Google wins this appeal, it keeps its tight grip on the Play Store, keeping alternative app stores (https://reinouttebrake.com/stories/the-rise-of-the-epic-games-store-can-it-ever-compete-with-steam) out and limiting developer freedom . If Google loses , it could open the doors for: ✅ More competition in app stores (Epic Games Store, Amazon Appstore, others). ✅ Lower fees for developers (no more mandatory 30% cuts). ✅ More choice for consumers in how they download apps. This is why Microsoft, the FTC, and even the U.S. Department of Justice are backing Epic. They see Google’s gatekeeping as a real problem. Google’s Defense: “But Apple Won!” Google’s argument is simple: “If Apple won against Epic, we should too.” Their lawyer, Jessica Ellsworth , claims that Apple and Google are fierce competitors and should be treated the same. But the judges aren’t buying it. One judge even pointed out: ❌ Apple makes iPhones. Google does not. ❌ Apple runs a closed system. Google influences an “open” one (Android). It’s a key difference , and it could mean Google’s appeal fails . Stay Connected: Gaming Trends, Insights, and Your Take Thank you for reading. Every day I look at the gaming industry , read up on things, and talk to industry people. In my Medium blogs (https://medium.com/@reinouttebrake), I try to give my readers and 1.5K followers a solid sense of trends, analysis, investments, and more in gaming . If you found this interesting, I’d appreciate it if you shared the article — but even more, I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments!